The Conversation You’d Rather Not Have
How to prep for the chat you’re feeling resistant to
A team leader I coach has a small beef with a colleague. Nothing was on fire but something needed to be addressed.
The colleague had published an update on a project their two teams share. The update celebrated the progress the teams had made. It didn’t mention my client’s team, what that team had delivered, or the fact that my client’s team will be orchestrating the project going forward.
Nothing was on fire. This wasn’t a crisis, and my client knew it.
Left alone, though, the omission has a cost. People across the organization may not understand how the progress came together or what to expect next. And a team whose work goes unmentioned tends to bring a little less of itself the next time.
My client knew a conversation was called for. They also felt two things pulling the other way. One was the worry that raising it would create awkwardness with a colleague they work alongside. The other was older and more familiar: when conflict shows up, their natural inclination is to withdraw, to flee the possible conflict.
I suspect most leaders recognize that pull. Most of the conversations are the medium-sized ones, with a peer or someone more senior, where the stakes feel just low enough to justify letting it go.
So we built a plan. Here are the steps we worked out, and the research behind them.
1. Set an intention
Before the conversation, answer two questions. What do I want to convey? And how do I want to show up while I convey it: open, clear, curious, directive, confident?
For my client, the first answer was simple. The organization should know what the team contributed and that the team is leading the work from here. The second question matters just as much, because how you show up shapes how the message lands.
An intention gives you direction. It works best when it’s paired with a plan, because research on goals has long shown a gap between what people intend to do and what they do. Step two closes that gap.
2. Build a game plan, including a backup
Decide ahead of time how you’re going to express yourself. Then plan for the moment the other person doesn’t respond the way you’d like: “If X happens, I will choose to do Y.”
Psychologists call the if-then format an implementation intention, and a meta-analysis of 94 studies by Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran found it had a medium-to-large effect on whether people followed through on their goals. It’s a shortcut for the brain, which likes to (believe it or not) minimize decision making.
If-then plans help most when the goal really matters to you and something in you tends to get in the way. That describes a leader who cares about their team getting its due and whose instinct is to retreat.
So if you know your pattern, plan for it by name. For example: “If my colleague gets defensive, I will take a breath and ask a question.”
3. Notice your response to being challenged
Being challenged shows up somewhere. For some people it’s physical: the throat tightens, the chest tightens, the stomach sours. For others it’s a feeling of awkwardness, or a pull toward fleeing.
Learn your own signal. It’s the earliest warning you’ll get that you are about to react. And it can be a cue to what to do next.
There is research behind this. In a UCLA brain-imaging study led by Matthew Lieberman, putting a name to an emotion was associated with less activity in the amygdala, which acts as the brain’s alarm. The study was small, and the effect is likely modest, but it points in a useful direction.
Notice the response, whether it arrives as an emotion or as a physical sensation, and name it. You can’t choose your response to something you haven’t noticed. When you have awareness, you also have choice.
4. Create space so you can respond, not react
When the challenge comes and your signal fires, buy yourself a moment. Breathe. Then ask an open-ended question: “Oh, that’s interesting. Tell me more.”
The breath does real work. A 2024 review of 31 studies found that slow breathing reliably lowers heart rate and blood pressure in the short term. That buys you the pause you need.
The ‘tell me more’ question does two jobs. It gives you time, and it gets the other person sharing their perspective and experience. Powerful questions tend to start with “what,” “how,” or “tell me about.”
I steer clients away from beginning questions with “why.” It can sound like a demand for justification, and it pulls people backward into defending what already happened.
Research backs the curious approach. Studies of conversational receptiveness, meaning language that shows real engagement with the other person’s view, link it to less escalation between people who disagree. They also show it can be learned.
Then say what you came to say
One caution for those of us who lean toward withdrawal: curiosity can become a comfortable place to hide. Questions open the conversation. They don’t replace the message you set in step one. Once you’ve heard the other person out, come back to it and say it plainly.
Then make sure it landed. I wrote about that in The Message You Sent Isn’t the Message They Got.
Practice in low stakes situations
None of this is easy to do for the first time in a high-stakes moment. So practice in low-stakes, non-threatening situations. Notice your signal, take the breath, ask the question. That’s how you build some muscle and habit around it before you need it.
Lean into what you can control
You can’t script how the other person responds. You can decide how you prepare and how you show up.
Set the intention. Build the plan. Notice your signal. Create space. Then say what needs saying.
Most of the difficult conversations leaders face look like my client’s. They aren’t existential. They’re easy to skip, and skipping them carries a cost.
What’s the conversation you’ve been avoiding?
Schedule time with me if you’d like to talk about what you don’t want to talk about:
Sources
- Gollwitzer & Oettingen, “Planning Promotes Goal Striving”, summarizing the Gollwitzer & Sheeran (2006) meta-analysis
- National Cancer Institute, “Implementation Intentions”, on when if-then plans help most
- UCLA Health on Lieberman et al. (2007), “Putting Feelings Into Words”
- Shao, Man & Lee (2024), slow-paced breathing meta-analysis
- Yeomans, Minson, Collins & Dorison, on conversational receptiveness







